By Kathleen Bagg
Earlier this month, Bishop Erik T. Pohlmeier of the Diocese of St. Augustine released his second statement on immigration in 2025, urging Catholics to approach the issue through the lens of the Gospel. His statement, “Beyond Borders: A Call to Christian Compassion,” emphasized that immigration decisions must begin with an understanding of human dignity and compassion, reminding the faithful that every person is made in the image and likeness of God.
Days later, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis announced plans to open a “Deportation Depot” at Bakersville Correctional Institution in North Florida — a facility located within the territory of the Diocese of St. Augustine. While the bishop’s statement was issued before the governor’s announcement, his message speaks directly to the moral responsibilities such policies raise.
“Nations have the right to protect their borders, but that responsibility must never overshadow the greater truth that every person is made in the image and likeness of God,” Bishop Pohlmeier said. “Many individuals held in detention are not hardened criminals. Some have legal protections, are awaiting hearings, or have come here seeking safety and a better life. They still deserve fair treatment, compassion, and due process under the law. Our starting point must be to see the person first, then work for just solutions that uphold both the common good and the sanctity of every life.”
The bishop’s message echoes concerns voiced by Archbishop Thomas Wenski of Miami, who has publicly criticized conditions at another Florida detention facility nicknamed “Alligator Alcatraz.” Archbishop Wenski described the site as inhumane, cautioned against demeaning language, and emphasized that many detainees are not dangerous criminals but people seeking protection or awaiting legal proceedings.
The Diocese of St. Augustine, which spans 17 counties in Northeast and North Central Florida, includes the proposed site of the new “Deportation Depot.” While Bishop Pohlmeier has not addressed the operational details of the planned facility, he affirmed that the diocese is making arrangements to provide pastoral care to detainees at the facility. His statement underscores a consistent theme: immigration enforcement must be measured against the demands of the Gospel, the sanctity of life, and the obligation to extend compassion to all — especially the poor and vulnerable.
To read Bishop Pohlmeier’s 2025 statements on immigration, visit https://dosafl.com/immigration/
